Updated
SEO reports love numbers. Domain authority, keyword counts, visibility scores, bounce rates. Most of them don’t tell a business owner the one thing they want to know: is this bringing in customers?
Here’s what to track, where to find it, and what to do with it.
The two free tools you need
- Google Search Console shows how your site performs in Google search: which searches you show up for, how often, your average position, and clicks. It also reports indexing and technical problems.
- Google Analytics 4 (GA4) shows what visitors do once they arrive: which pages they view, how engaged they are, and whether they call, submit a form, or buy.
Search Console tells you about the search. Analytics tells you about the visit. You need both.
The SEO metrics that matter
In Search Console
- Impressions: how often you appeared in results. Your visibility.
- Clicks: how often people chose you.
- Click-through rate (CTR): clicks divided by impressions. Low CTR on high-impression pages means your titles and descriptions need work.
- Average position: useful for spotting queries on page 2 that are close to page 1.
- Queries: the actual searches. The most valuable report in SEO.
- Page indexing: pages Google won’t index, and why. (See pages not getting indexed.)
In GA4
- Organic search sessions (Reports → Acquisition → Traffic acquisition, filter to Organic Search)
- Engagement rate and engagement time by landing page. (More on engagement metrics.)
- Key events (conversions): calls, form submissions, bookings, purchases, set up as key events
- Revenue from organic for online stores
Outside both
- Google Business Profile: calls, direction requests, and website clicks from your local listing
- Call tracking: which calls came from organic search
- Your CRM or sales data: which leads turned into revenue
Metrics to treat with caution
- Keyword rankings for vanity terms. Ranking #1 for something nobody buys from doesn’t matter.
- Total traffic. Traffic from the wrong audience looks good in a chart and does nothing for revenue.
- Third-party scores like domain authority. Handy for comparisons, but Google doesn’t use them.
Why traffic can drop while visibility holds
With AI Overviews answering more questions directly in search results, many sites see impressions hold steady or rise while clicks fall. That’s not always a problem. Watch whether leads and sales from search hold up, and whether your brand is being shown and cited. We wrote about this shift in Website Traffic Down? Here’s How AI Changed Search.
Turn data into decisions
A useful monthly SEO review answers four questions:
- Are leads and sales from search up or down?
- Which pages are gaining or losing impressions and clicks? Update the losers.
- Which queries are on page 2? Improve those pages next. (See SEO quick wins.)
- Are there new indexing or technical problems? Fix them before they spread.
Set it up right
- Verify your domain in Search Console and link it to GA4
- Set up key events for every way a customer can reach you
- Exclude your own team’s visits
- Use UTM tags on email and social links so they don’t blur into organic
The bottom line
SEO analytics only matters if it changes what you do next. Track visibility, clicks, and above all the calls, forms, and sales that come from search, then act on what the numbers show each month.
Want reporting that shows what’s actually working?
The BBS Agency builds Growth Engine plans for local service businesses and eCommerce brands. That’s SEO, plus search everywhere optimization across Google, other search engines, and AI, plus paid advertising, all aimed at the searches that turn into leads and sales.
Book a meeting with Vince and we’ll walk through your numbers together.